Types of bariatric surgery

The three types of Bariatric Surgery

Restrictive procedures

Vertical-banded gastroplasty and adjustable gastric banding

In restrictive surgery, the size of the stomach is dramatically reduced. This type of surgery makes a person very full, very fast. Overeating results in a very unpleasant feeling and often vomiting. After a restrictive procedure, weight loss is the result of not being able to consume calories. 

 

Malabsorptive procedures with some restriction 

Biliopancreatic diversion with duodenal switch

In malabsorptive surgery, a large portion of the small intestine is bypassed, making food you eat pass through only a part of the small intestine. Weight loss following this type of procedure is the result of an inability to absorbed calories. This is because food does not come in contact with the bypassed portion of the small intestine. Although malabsorptive surgery can result in tremendous weight loss, it does have some drawbacks.
more about restrictive gastric bypass surgery

Restrictive procedures with minimal malabsorption

Roux-en-Y gastric bypass

The most popular weight loss surgery, Roux-en-Y procedure, is both restrictive and malabsorptive and will be discussed a little later.

Bariatric surgery can be performed by both an open technique and a laparoscopic technique. The laparoscopic technique has currently become the more popular approach.

Gastric Banding

Gastric banding, also known as lap band surgery, uses an inflatable silicone band to divide the stomach and create a very small stomach pouch.

Read more about Gastric Banding

Vertical-banded gastroplasty and gastric banding

Vertical-banded Gastroplasty and Gastric Banding are purely restrictive procedures. In vertical-banded gastroplasty, the stomach is stapled fairly close to where the esophagus (food tube) meets the stomach. The staples are placed in a vertical fashion and a polypropylene (plastic) band is placed near the bottom of the staple line. The stapling results in a very small stomach while the band restricts how quickly food can leave this reduced pouch.

Vertical-banded Gastroplasty

Vertical-banded gastroplasty advantages

  • No dumping syndrome
  • No nutritional deficiencies/malabsorption

Vertical-banded gastroplasty disadvantages

  • Needs strict patient compliance to diet
  • High fiber foods and foods with a more dense, natural consistency can become very difficult to eat, while highly refined foods cause little discomfort. Most people who regain any weight lost after surgery do so because choosing "healthier" foods are harder to digest, while "junk" food pass easily.
  • VBG is in no way a magic bullet or pill. It must be emphasized that lifestyle changes, i.e. diet Vertical-banded Gastroplasty and exercise, are absolutely imperative for weight loss to occur and be maintained. Realistic expectations are imperative.
  • Reversal of a VBG requires a much more complex and intensive surgical process than getting the VBG. When removal of a polyurethane band is involved (polyurethane was predominantly used in the 1980s and 90s), it likely has built substantial scar tissue that must also be removed, depending on how long ago the VBG took place. Removal of the staples involves stitching the previously separated parts of the stomach back together. For these reasons, a reversal should only be considered if there are serious medical complications.
  • Vomiting and severe discomfort if food is not properly chewed or if food is eaten too quickly.
  • As with any surgical procedure, there are risks of complications. It has been observed that approximately one in every hundred patients undergoing VBG die within a year. There may also be other medical complications down the road, but the risk is relatively low
  • Not adjustable

Long term

Although restrictive operations lead to weight loss in almost all patients, they are less successful than malabsorptive operations in achieving substantial, long-term weight loss. About 30 percent of those who undergo VBG achieve normal weight, and about 80 percent achieve some degree of weight loss. Most studies have suggested that 10 years after surgery, only 10% of patients maintain a minimum weight loss of at least 50% of their total excess weight at the time of their initial surgery.

Some patients regain weight. Others are unable to adjust their eating habits and fail to lose the desired weight. Successful results depend on the patient’s willingness to adopt a long-term plan of healthy eating and regular physical activity.

Does vertical-banded gastroplasty result in any vitamin or mineral deficiencies?

In the stomach food comes in contact with gastric acid. Iron found in foods such as spinach, raisins, and red meat requires contact with gastric acid to covert it from the ferrous form, which is not readily absorbed adequately, anemia can result. The stomach also contains something called intrinsic factor, which aids in the absorption of vitamin B12.

Vitamin B12 deficiency can result in a condition called pernicious anemia. Vertical-banded gastroplasty can result in a deficiency of both iron and vitamin B12. Although this is generally not a major problem, supplements of both iron and vitamin B12 are usually necessary. Because of the potential for vitamin and mineral deficiencies following gastric bypass surgery, it is crucial for you to maintain regular follow-up with the nurses, doctors, and dietitians at your gastric bypass
center.

Do people keep their weight off following vertical-banded gastroplasty?

While initial weight loss is quite good with verticalbanded gastroplasty, long-term maintenance is poor. Unlike most other forms of gastric bypass surgery, following vertical-banded gastroplastymost people are not troubled by eating sweets, and as a result they may consume excessive amounts of sweets. This behavior has been linked to poor long-term weight loss. At ten years this procedure has an 80 percent failure rate (meaning much of the initial weight lost is regained). In addition 15 to 20 percent of people who have this procedure require a re-operation due to blockage of the
polypropylene band or reflux of stomach acid into the esophagus. Because of these difficulties, it is unlikely that your doctor will suggest verticalbanded gastroplasty.

The Roux-en-Y gastric bypass procedure

Gastric bypass is the favored bariatric surgery in the United States. Surgeons prefer this surgery because it's safer and has fewer complications than other available weight-loss surgeries. It can provide long-term, consistent weight loss if accompanied with ongoing behavior changes.

Gastric bypass isn't for everyone with obesity, however. It's a major procedure that poses significant risks and side effects and requires permanent changes in your lifestyle. Before deciding to go forward with the surgery, it's important to understand what's involved and what lifestyle changes you must make. In large part, the success of the surgery is up to you.

How is Roux-en-Y gastric bypass surgery done?

Surgical techniques

Laparoscopic surgery is performed using several small incisions, or ports, one of which conveys a surgical telescope connected to a video camera, and others permit access of specialized operating instruments. The surgeon actually views his operation on a video screen. The method is also called limited access surgery, reflecting both the limitation on handling and feeling tissues, and also the limited resolution and two-dimensionality of the video image. With experience, a skilled laparoscopic surgeon can perform most procedures as expeditiously as with an open incision — with the option of using an incision should the need arise.

The Laparoscopic Gastric Bypass, Roux-en-Y, first performed in 1993, is regarded as one of the most difficult procedures to perform by limited access techniques, but use of this method has greatly popularized the operation, with benefits which include shortened hospital stay, reduced discomfort, shorter recovery time, less scarring, and minimal risk of incisional hernia.

Before gastric bypass, food enters your stomach and passes into the small intestine. After surgery, food is redirected so that it bypasses most of your stomach and the first section of your small intestine (duodenum). Food flows directly into the middle section of your small intestine (jejunum), limiting absorption of calories.

In gastric bypass (Roux-en-Y gastric bypass) the surgeon creates a small pouch at the top of your stomach and adds a bypass around a segment of your stomach and small intestine.

The surgeon staples your stomach across the top, sealing it off from the rest of your stomach. The resulting pouch is about the size of a walnut and can hold only about an ounce of food. The pouch is physically separated from the rest of the stomach. Then, the surgeon cuts the small intestine and sews part of it directly onto the pouch.

This connection redirects the food, bypassing most of your stomach and the first section of your small intestine, the duodenum. Food enters directly into the second section of your small intestine, the jejunum, limiting your ability to absorb calories.

Even though food never enters the lower part of your stomach, the stomach stays healthy and continues to secrete digestive juices to mix with food in your small intestine. Because of its low complication rate and high degree of success, the Roux-en-Y is generally accepted to be the best and safest bariatric procedure.

Some surgeons perform this operation by using a laparoscope — a small, tubular instrument with a camera attached — through short incisions in the abdomen (laparoscopic gastric bypass). The tiny camera on the tip of the scope allows the surgeon to see inside your abdomen.

Recent studies show patients who have had laparoscopic weight loss surgery experience:

  • Less pain after surgery
  • Easier breathing and lung function
  • Fewer wound complications such as infection or hernia
  • Quicker return to pre-surgical levels of activity What happens if the operation cannot beperformed or completed by the laparoscopic method?

In some patients the laparoscopic method does not work effectively. Factors that may increase the possibility of choosing or converting to the "open" procedure may include:

Roux-en-Y gastric bypass procedure

A history of prior abdominal surgery causing dense scar tissue

  • Inability to visualize organs
  • Bleeding problems during the operation

Roux-en-Y gastric bypass procedure If bariatric surgery is performed laparoscopically and complications occur during the operation, your doctor may choose to perform open surgery.

The decision to perform the open procedure is a judgment decision made by your surgeon either before or during the actual operation. The decision to convert to an open (conventional) procedure is strictly based on patient safety.

Risks And Complications Of the Roux-en-Y Procedure

As with any major surgery, there can be complications. One of the most common in the Roux-en-Y procedure is blood clots in the legs. This occurs in about 0.2 percent of people undergoing the Roux-en-Y procedure. The clots have the potential to travel to the lungs, where they can have serious consequences. In order to prevent this you will be given blood thinners following surgery. You may also be asked to wear compression stockings. These are very tight stockings that have been proven to reduce blood clots in postoperative patients. Your doctor will want you to get up and walk as soon after surgery as possible. Early ambulation has also been proven to reduce the risk of blood clots. Finally,
although the risk of blood clots is highest in the days immediately following surgery, if you notice unexplained swelling in your legs or sudden shortness of breath once you are home from hospital, contact your physician and get yourself evaluated. Another risk is that occasionally food or liquids will leak out of the stomach instead of traveling directly into the jejunum. While this can be a serious complication occurring in about 1 percent of procedures, it can generally be
corrected. If this happens to you, you will need to return to the operating room. In general, one day after your gastric bypass surgery you will go down to the radiology department and drink something called gastrographin (this is a liquid that will show up on an x-ray). After you drink the gastrographin you will have an x-ray to make sure there is no leakage. If there is a problem, it can be addressed immediately.

Complications of Roux-en-Y gastric bypass

Early complications:

  • Anastomotic leak (1-3%)
  • Pulmonary embolism, deep vein thrombosis (<1%)
  • Wound infection (more common with open approach)
  • Gastrointestinal hemorrhage, bleeding (0.5-2%)
  • Respiratory insufficiency, pneumonia
  • Acute distention of the distal stomach

Late complications:

  • Stomal stenosis (20%)
  • Bowel obstruction, small bowel obstruction (1%)
  • Internal hernia
  • Cholelithiasis
  • Micronutrient deficiencies
  • Marginal ulcer
  • Staple line disruption
  • Ventral hernia formation ( more prevalent after open approach)

Weight loss with the Roux-en-Y procedure

Weight loss with the Roux-en-Y procedure is quite good, with most people losing between 65 to 75 percent of their excess weight within the first year. While some people do gain a considerable amount of weight back over the following three to five years, most do not. The first six months after the surgery is known as the rapid weight loss phase.

Immediately following surgery your stomach will be quite swollen and you simply will not be hungry. At this stage you will be taking in liquids only and your weight will fall dramatically. As you begin to eat real food weight loss slows a little, but you can expect very steady and substantial weight loss for the first six months. At about six months many
people find that their appetite returns. Nonetheless weight loss generally continues for another six months, but at a slower rate. In general, after about a year, further weight loss becomes more difficult without real effort. By a year most people will have lost about 65 to 75 percent of their excess weight. This means that in order to achieve their ideal body weight they need to continue to lose. Unfortunately, at about a year a person’s new stomach will have stretched a bit, making it much easier to consume larger portions.

At this point food choices and exercise help determine if a person will achieve his or her ideal body weight.

Within the first two years of surgery, you can expect to lose 50 percent to 60 percent of your excess weight. If you closely follow dietary and exercise recommendations, you can keep most of that weight off long term.

In addition to dramatic weight loss, gastric bypass surgery may improve or resolve the following conditions associated with obesity:

  • Type 2 (adult-onset) diabetes
  • High blood pressure
  • High blood cholesterol
  • Obstructive sleep apnea
  • Gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD)

The improvements observed in type 2 diabetes, high blood pressure and high blood triglycerides may significantly decrease the risk of cardiovascular events in people who have undergone gastric bypass surgery compared with those people who did not have surgery. Also, gastric bypass surgery may reduce the risk of dying of diabetes, heart disease and cancer. The surgery has also shown to improve mobility and quality of life for people who are severely overweight.

Gastric banding

Gastric banding, also known as lap band surgery, uses an inflatable silicone band to divide the stomach and create a very small stomach pouch. While the diameter of the band is generally about five centimeters, the surgeon can adjust the
diameter by pumping saline into the band from a reservoir implanted under the patient’s skin. Just as with vertical-banded gastroplasty, blockage of the band can be problematic, and unfortunately the reservoir implanted beneath the skin doesn’t last forever. Consequently, weight regain with this method can also occur. In general gastric banding
is no more successful than vertical-banded gastroplasty, and it too can result in iron and vitamin B12 deficiency. Laparoscopic gastric banding requires more frequent visits for band adjustment.

Complications of the adjustable gastric band procedure

Early complications:

  • Injury of the stomach or esophagus
  • Bleeding
  • Food intolerance
  • Wound infection
  • Pneumonia

Late complications:

  • Band slippage
  • Food intolerance or noncompliance to band
  • Pouch dilatation
  • Band erosion into the stomach
  • Port complications
  • Re-operation rate (2-41%)
  • Esophageal dilatation
  • Failure to lose weight
  • Port infection, band infection
  • Leakage of the balloon or tubing
  • Mortality rate

Biliopancreatic diversion bypass

The biliopancreatic diversion bypass is performed through open surgery with one long incision, leaving a permanent scar. It is less common and more complicated than the Roux-en-Y-gastric bypass. In the biliopancreatic diversion, portions of
the stomach are removed and the bypass is attached to the distal illium. This procedure is not widely used, because there is more risk of nutritional deficiencies.

The pancreas and gall bladder have ducts that carry digestive juices and enzymes to the duodenum. These enzymes and digestive juices allow for the breakdown of the food we eat. Once food is broken down it can be absorbed in the
duodenum and jejunum of the lower intestine.

Since this procedure prevents the digestive juices and enzymes in the duodenum and jejunum from making contact with food until almost the end of the ileum, calories from food are simply not absorbed effectively. This allows dramatic weight loss to occur, but it also results in a number of complications.

Complications of the Biliopancreatic diversion with duodenal switch

  • Fat malabsorption results in diarrhea and foulsmelling gas in approximately 30% of patients.
  • The potential nutritional deficiencies mandate frequent follow-up visits, with close monitoring and supplementation of multivitamins and minerals.
  • Malabsorption of fat soluble vitamins (vitamins A, D, E, and K)
  • Vitamin A deficiency, which causes night blindness
  • Vitamin D deficiency, which causes osteoporosis
  • Iron deficiency
  • Protein-energy malnutrition (may require a second operation to lengthen the common channel)